A SCHOOL LIBRARY COLLECTIONS, PROGRAMMES AND FREE VOLUNTARY READING OF SECONDARY SCHOOL STUDENTS IN IMO STATE

0
428

Table of Contents

Title Page                                                                                                   i          

Approval page                                                                                          iii        

Certification                                                                                              iv

Table of Contents                                                                          v

Abstract                                                                                                      xi

CHAPTER ONE:

Introduction                                                                                           1

Background of the Study                                                                   1

Statement of the Problem                                                                   7

Objective of the study                                                                8         

Research questions                                                                            9         

Hypotheses                                                                                          9

Significance of the study                                                                 9

Scope of the Study                                                                        10       

CHAPTER TWO: Review of Related Literature

Conceptual framework                                                                     12       

Concept of reading                                                                            12       

Concept of free voluntary reading     

School library collection for free voluntary reading                20       

Programmes for developing free voluntary reading                   22       

Influence of school library collection, programmes on free

voluntary reading                                                                  26

Constraints to free voluntary reading                                              27

Steps school library will take for improvement of free voluntary reading            30

Theoretical Framework

   Constructionist theory                                                                   34       

Reading hypothesis model theory                                                    37

Review of related empirical studies                                                 37

Summary of literature review                                                               44       

CHAPTER THREE:

Research Method                                                47

Design of the study                                                                                     47       

Area of the study                                                                                           47       

Population of the study                                                                                  47

Sample and sampling techniques                                                                48

Instruments for data collection                                                                   48

Validation of the instrument                                                                      49

Reliability of the instruments                                                                  50

Methods of data collection                                                                   51

Methods of data analysis                                                                        51

CHAPTER FOUR: Presentation and Analysis of Data                           

Research question 1                                                                      52

Research question 2                                                                       53

Research question 3                                                                         56

Research question 4                                                                   60

Research question 5                                                                       62

Research question 6                                                                     64

Research question 7                                                                 65

Hypotheses 1                                                    67

Hypotheses 2                                                                                             68

Summary of the findings                                    69                                                                                           

CHAPTERFIVE: Discussion, Conclusion and Recommendations

Discussion of the findings                                                                      71

Implications                                                                      76

Recommendations                                                                                       78

Suggestions for further studies                                                                          78

Limitations of the study                                                                              79

Conclusions                                                                                                         79

REFERENCES                                                       80                                                                                                                                                       

APPENDICES

Appendix 1:   Distribution of population to their school                            93

Appendix 2:   Questionnaire for students       94

Appendix 3:   Interview schedule for teacher librarian                               98

Appendix 4:   Observation checklist                                                             99

Appendix 5:   Crombach Alpha formula                                                     100

Appendix6:    Formular for calculating the mean              100

Appendix 7:   Formular for calculating standard deviation             100

Appendix 8:    formular for calculating regression analysis                       101

LIST OF TABLES

Table

1.   Frequency and mean ratingof the respondents at each level of free voluntary

reading                                                                                                                        52

2.   Frequencies and percentage of respondents on the availability of school

 library collectionfor free voluntary reading                                                               54                                                                                                                                           

3.   Frequencies and percentages of readingprogrammes employed

 to promote free voluntary reading                                                                             57

      4.   Analysis of reading progrmmes employed by libraries to promote reading               58          5.       Summary of analysis influence of school library collection on free

voluntary reading                                                                                                        61                                                                                                 

      6.    Summary of analysis of influence of reading programmes on free voluntary

Reading                                                                                                                       63

7.   Mean rating and standard deviations of respondents on the constraints                  

      to their free voluntary reading                                                                          64

8.   Mean rating and standard deviations of respondents on the steps that should be

      taken by the school library to improve free voluntary reading among students         66

9.   Summary of student’s t-statistics on the influenceof school library

      collections on free voluntary reading                                                                          67

10. Summary of students’t-statistics on the influence of school library

      Programmes on students free voluntary reading                                                        68

ABSTRACT

Free voluntary reading has the potential for increased self concept, reading ability, academic success, social, physical, mental, vocabulary and grammatical growth of secondary school students. The school library with its collections and reading programmes has the responsibility for the inculcation and promotion of free voluntary reading in secondary school students. Despite all these, literature and observation have shown that secondary school students in Nigeria including Imo State are not reading as they should. Students spent more time in viewing television and video programmes rather than on literacy activities. The purpose of this study therefore is to investigate the influence school library collection programmes and free voluntary reading of students in Imo State. The study specifically intended to: determine the level of students free voluntary reading; determine the school library collection available for free voluntary reading; ascertain the reading programmes employed to promote free voluntary reading, establish the influence of school library collection and reading programmes on free voluntary reading; identify constraints to free voluntary reading and identify steps for improving free voluntary reading of students. Seven research questions and two null hypotheses guided the study. The study is based on two theories, the constructionist theory and the reading hypothesis model theory. The study employed descritive design. The population of the study comprised 36 secondary schools in Imo State that have libraries.  Multi stage sampling technique was employed in this study. The first stage was the purposive sampling of the schools that had functional libraries in the state. A total of 29 schools that had functional libraries were selected. The second stage was the proportionate stratified random sampling of students from JSS 1, SS 1 and SS 2.  Applying this technique, a total of 1, 473 school students were randomly selected from the 29 schools. All the 29 teacher librarians in the 29 schools were also selected for this study. Questionnaire, interview and observation were used to collect data from respondents.  The data was analyzed using frequency tables, percentage, average, mean, standard deviations pie chart, bar chart and regression analysis. The study revealed that  students do not read in great quantity, non-fiction books are more in the collection (93.43%), fiction books and periodicals are grossly inadequate, access to reading materials, debate, lending of books and assistance in book selection were the major programmes employed (2.65). There is positive relationship between school library collections and free voluntary reading; there is strong relationship between school library reading programmes and free voluntary reading. There is significant relationship (p < 0.5) between fiction books and free voluntary reading. These are significant relationship (p < 0.05) between reading programmes and free voluntary reading of students. Also distraction from television programmes (2.85 ± 0.89) and none teaching of reading in the schools (2.73 ± 0.90) were major factors affecting free voluntary reading. Lending of books (3.32 ± 0.67) and provision of newspaper and magazines (3.32 ± 0.68) were steps for improving free voluntary reading.

CHAPTER ONE

INTRODUCTION

Background to the Study

Reading is an activity which helps to develop the mind and personality of human beings and ultimately enriches their intellectual lives. As students learn to enjoy reading, learning becomes relevant and in that way improves their reading ability and self concept. The act of reading is an act of communication and interpretation. Reading according to McArthur (1996) is a process of extracting meaning from written or printed language.  This implies that reading involves complex activities which the eyes, the mind, the brain or the central nervous system collaborates in the process of perceiving, analyzing, reasoning, interpreting and solving.  Reading concerns both explicit meaning and implicit meaning. That is, the reader must be able to translate and interpret the written words into meaningful language that will help him solve his educational, social, emotional and political problems.

            It is against this background that both the Universal Basic Education (Nigeria, 2000) and the National Policy on Education (Nigeria, 2004) emphasized basic functional literacy as one of the key objectives of the child’s education.  Researches have shown that one of the ways of achieving functional literacy is through free voluntary reading.  Free voluntary reading is variously called leisure reading or pleasure reading.  Krashan (1993:X) provides an operational definition of free voluntary reading as “the reading you are doing because you want to”.  According to him, in this type of reading students are free to choose the reading resources they want to read, choose not to report in class on the reading they have done.  One can add to this definition by noting that free voluntary reading refers to reading one does without being compelled to do so.  It is the reading one does for the joy of it.  This type of reading is anxiety free and it is not entirely for utilitarian or vocational bases.  A student reads for pleasure when the student reads book that are not entirely recommended by the curriculum.  It is a reading a student does not in anticipation for any examination but for the joy of it and when the student always and persistently does that he will cultivate the habit of pleasure reading.

            Many factors combined to develop robust free voluntary reading habit.  These include provision of varied and relevant reading materials, access to reading materials, motivational reading experiences and conducive environment.

            In this regard, the role of school libraries is vital as libraries provide access for reading materials and programmes that encourage reading.  The school library or school library media centre is a systematically organized collection of learning resources consisting of print and non print information materials supporting educational activities in the school (Kolade, 1998).  School library is the type of library found in the primary, and secondary schools.

            School library collection are information materials collected, processed, and organized for use for the promotion of educational activities and implementation of the curriculum in the school.  School library collection can be variously referred to as reading resources, reading materials or information materials.  These reading resources include textbooks in different subjects, supplementary books, reference books, pamphlets, story books, government documents, newspapers, and magazines, non-print materials like motion picture, films strips, video tapes, record players, computers and digital resources.

            For the purpose of this study, school library collection are grouped into three major heading namely; non-fiction, fiction and periodicals.  Non-fiction reading resources include all recommended textbooks and reference books in different subjects recommended for the achievement of the curriculum and all educational activities in the school.  Fiction materials are books with imaginative themes, titles and characters and they include romance novel, adventure books, myth and legends, fantasy tales, stories about people and families, sports sorties and science fiction.  Periodicals are materials on topical issues and they include newspapers and magazines.

            Access to these reading materials especially fiction, newspapers and magazines will whet adolescent reading appetite and motivate them to read.  There is a relationship between print access and print exposure and the amount of free voluntary reading done by students.  The size of the collection equally has an influence on the reader.  For free voluntary reading to be inculcated and maintain in students, large and relevant collection` of fiction and periodicals must be provided in the school library.  Students in schools with larger collection made better gains in reading.  Although people can pick any book that attract their eyes and read at one time or the other, fiction books had been consistently proved to be important resource in the inculcation and improvement of free voluntary reading in students.  Traw  (1993) revealed in his study that when students were given freedom to choose books for pleasure reading, they chose fiction books on sports, romance, mystery, violence and fantasy.

            Apart from provision of reading materials, school libraries provide reading programmes that motivate students to read for pleasure.  Reading programmes are reading activities school libraries provide to create awareness of the collection and motivate students to read for pleasure. They are reading experiences provided in the school library to encourage students’ use of the collection and inculcate free voluntary reading habits in students.  These programmes include display, exhibition, access to reading materials, lending of books, storytelling, debate, book talks (Carbo and Cole 1995) Engaging students in variety of reading experiences through book talks, readers theatre, storytelling will help students develop habit of listening, comprehension and recall.  Students’ participation in debate and book club will challenge them to read widely and seek information in the library.

            Providing equity of access to reading resources, engaging authors’ visits, and supporting books fairs, exhibition and displays are means to building lifelong readers.  Specifically reading promotion is one of the cardinal roles of school library (Dike, 1998).  The federal government document on Minimum Standards for School Libraries (1992: 9&10) recognized this role. Four out of the nine contributions expected of the school libraries in Nigeria are on reading development.  According to the Minimum Standard, school libraries:

  • Promote the development of reading skills and encourage long term learning habits through reading, listening to and viewing a variety of learning materials.  Reading habits form the key to continuous success in school as well as personal enrichment of the student/pupils.
  • Provide opportunities for further reading and use of materials other than prescribed classroom textbooks.
  • Stimulate research and independent study by providing a wide variety of materials so that it does not only supply information in printed form, but also in pictures, films, tapes etc.  This makes learning more exciting.
  • Provide materials for recreation and encourage students/pupils to read for pleasure.

Free voluntary reading also helps student in the acquisition of other language skills, success in their academic, improved reading ability, vocabulary knowledge, emotional stability, enjoyment of leisure hours, and increased knowledge of political, economical and social issues in his environment.

The secondary school age is that of adolescence, which is a transitional period between childhood and adulthood. Piaget (1998) and Erickson (1998) in their different studies identified general characteristics of adolescents as formal operations, redefinition of friendship and the growth of self awareness.  The adolescent departs from concrete thinking to thinking in formal operations which are characterized with servicing of one’s thought processes and personality characteristics, questioning of the meaning of political structures, religious ideologies, analyses of nature of feelings such as love and hate, and to attemptto understand the significance of life itself. Formal operations is a time of hypothetical-deductive reasoning which allows the adolescent to set up a variety of hypotheses, rank them in order of probability and then test them to generate alternatives when dealing with a problem.

The adolescent at this stage redefines friendship. There is a shift from external, action-oriented concepts of friendship to those that are internal and communication oriented.  They make friends on the basis of personal qualities.  They see relationship as an opportunity to satisfy their need to communicate physical changes, changed social roles and expectations, and intellectual changes related to formal reasoning all combined to challenge the adolescent to integrate the past, present, and future in order to establish a stable and consistent sense of self. This is called crisis of identity. These characteristics and changes come with personal needs adolescents seek to satisfy.

 Arbuthnot (1964) enumerated some of the basic needs of adolescents which they struggle to satisfy thus: competence, material security, emotional security, acceptance, play and aesthetic satisfaction. Struggling to satisfy his needs, the adolescent is seeking to maintain the balance between personal happiness and social approval, and this is not an easy task. Reading materials in different format can help him directly or indirectly to meet some of these needs.  Aguolu and Aguolu (2000) posit that without successful growth emotionally, mentally, socially and physically during this intermediate state of human development, their adulthood will be jeopardized. Therefore adolescents need to move beyond basic literacy to critical and recreational reading. Adolescents need to read judiciously in other to answer most of their questions and satisfy their needs.  Free voluntary reading is the key to life-long reading which result to personal development and enrichment, community development and knowledge of other people and the world.  In free voluntary reading, the adolescents are exposed to wider and broader reading through which they acquire knowledge of how others in their stage of development master and solve their problems.

In Imo State, secondary school students are not reading for pleasure as they should.  Most of the students do not engage in free voluntary reading rather they spent many hours viewing television programmes and home videos rather than engage in literacy activities.  Students read mostly to pass examinations and this is why they quickly stopped reading immediately they finished examinations.  This attitude to free voluntary reading might be the cause to mass failures in examination, lack of mastery in grammar and self expression, lack of self concept and disengagement from school.

Many factors had been attributed to be the cause of poor attitude to reading by students. These include dearth of interesting reading materials, poor reading culture in the society, poverty, illiteracy, lack of reading on the time table, lack of library hour on the time table, poor educational system which is examination oriented.

As a result of these problems of reading, there had been reading promotional programmes launched at various times by Reading Association of Nigeria (RAN) and National Library of Nigeria (NLN).  These promotional programmes had not yielded enough desired effect because theory is not practice. The talks were not merged with provision of books and establishment of reading programmes in the schools. Before students formed habit of reading, they must be provided with favourable reading environment in the school as the home is void of this.

The importance of school library in the promotion of free voluntary reading cannot be sufficiently emphasized. Outside Nigeria much research work had been done on the relationship of school libraries and free voluntary reading.  These studies revealed that where school libraries exist, they are major sources of reading materials (Krashan, 1993). They further found that access to school libraries results in more reading and that large and relevant school library collection result in higher reading scores and increased circulation.  Through their programmes and activities, school libraries promote free voluntary reading among students. In Nigeria as well Obi (1997) affirmed that a school library plays an important role in reading promotion when other libraries are remote and the home contains limited materials. From the forgoing, it is evident that school libraries in Nigeria are expected to play major roles in the promotion of free voluntary reading. In view of all these, this study will focus on school library collection and programmes and free voluntary reading of secondary schools students in Imo State.

Statement of the Problem 

A SCHOOL LIBRARY COLLECTIONS, PROGRAMMES AND FREE VOLUNTARY READING OF SECONDARY SCHOOL STUDENTS IN IMO STATE