AN APPRAISAL OF THE OFFENCE OF RAPE UNDER THE NIGERIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM 

0
985

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TITLE PAGE                                                                                                 i

CERTIFICATION                                                                                         ii

DEDICATION                                                                                               iii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS                                                                           iv

TABLE OF CONTENTS                                                                               vi

TABLES OF CASES                                                                                     x

TABLE OF STATUTES                                                                                xvi

ABBREVIATIONS                                                                                       xvii

ABSTRACT                                                                                                   xx

CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION

1.1       Background to Study                                                                                     1

1.2       Statement of Problem                                                                         3

1.3       Scope of the study                                                                              6

1.4       Objectives of the Study                                                                      7

1.5       Significance of the Study                                                                   7

1.6       Methodology of Research                                                                  9

1.7       Organization of Study                                                                                    9

1.8       Definition of Terms                                                                             10

CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW                                          14

CHAPTER THREE: A PANORAMA OF THE OFFENCE OF

RAPE UNDER THE NIGERIAN CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM

3.1       Definition of the Offence of Rape under the Nigerian Criminal

Justice System                                                                                     23

3.1.1    The Mens Rea                                                                                     28

3.1.2    The Actus Reus                                                                                   29

3.1.3    The Penal Code                                                                                   30

3.2       Capacity to Consummate the Offence of Rape                                  31

3.3       Examination of the point at which the offence of rape can be s

aid to be consummated                                                                       34

3.3.1    Penetration                                                                                          36

3.4       The Concept of Consent as a Vitiating Element                                 40

3.4.1    Consent by Force, Intimidation or Threat                                          41

3.4.2    Evidence of Past Sexual History of Victim and Consent                   41

3.5       The Proper Standard of Reasonability                                                42

3.6       The Concept of Fraud                                                                         45

3.7       The Effect of Administering Mind altering substances                      46

3.8       Non-Consensual Condom Removal                                                   49

3.9       Statutory Rape and Defilement of Girls; should there be a Merger?    51

3.9.1    Statutory Rape in Nigeria                                                                   52

3.9.2    Distinction between Statutory Rape and Defilement of Girls;

            should the Offences be Merged?                                                        53

3.10     Corroboration in Sexual Offences; the Propriety                               55

3.11     Attempted Rape                                                                                 56

CHAPTER FOUR: A PERUSAL OF THE OFFENCE OF RAPE

AS IT APPERTAINS TO PERSONS WHO CAN CONSUMMATE

THE OFFENCE AND THE OBJECT AND SUBJECT OF COMMISSION          

4.1       Capacity of a Man to Commit Rape                                                   59

4.1.1    Capacity of a man to rape in Nigeria                                                  62

4.2      The Ability of a Woman to Commit Rape                                            67

4.3       Can a Child below Twelve Years Rape?                                             73

4.4      What is the Propriety of the Assertion that Rape may be

           constituted as Between Men and Vice Versa?                                     73

4.5      The Object and Subject of Rape: Should their Meanings

           be expanded?                                                                             76           

4.5.1   The Need for Expansion of the Meanings of the Object and

           Subject of Rape                                                                                78

4.6      How has the Violence Against Persons (Prohibition) Act

           2015 Affected the Capacity of Persons who can Commit Rape?        79

4.6.1   Limitation of the Definition of the Offence of Rape as Contained

           in the Violence Against Persons Act                                                    83

4.7       The capacity of a Man to Rape the Wife and Vice Versa                   85

4.7.1    Can a Husband be said to commit Rape on the Wife                         85

4.7.2    Limitations to Marital Immunity                                                        88

4.7.3    Can a wife rape the husband?                                                             90

4.8       The Concept of Indecent Assault                                                       91

4.8.1    Elements of Indecent Assault                                                             92

4.8.2    Indecent Assault in Marital Relationships                                          95

4.9       Gentle Violence and Marital Rape: The Way Forward                       97

4.10     Acquaintance Rape                                                                             98

4.11     The Constitutional Right to Privacy vis á vis Rape Reporting           99

4.12     Health Consequences                                                                          101

CHAPTER FIVE: SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

5.1       Summary                                                                                             104

5.2       Conclusion                                                                                          108

5.3       Recommendations                                                                              110

BIBLIOGRAPHY                                                                            114