COMPARATIVE ASSESSMENT OF THE INHIBITORY POTENTIALS OF GARLIC AND TUMERIC IN TREATMENT OF VULVOVAGINAL CANDIDIASIS

0
397

ABSTRACT

The recurrent nature  of  yeast  infections  and  the  subsequent  use  of  antifungal  medicines  for treatment, pose a  potential  threat  to  women’s  health  and  safety  worldwide,  which  could also give rise to antifungal resistance. The aim of this study is to evaluate the antimicrobial efficacy of garlic and tumeric against  multi-drug  resistance  of  Candida albicans, associated with  Vulvovaginal  infection.  Results  of  the  anti-microbial  susceptibility test by disc diffusion method revealed that ethanolic extract of both herbal products, was generally more effective in inhibiting the growth of Candida albicans. As observed from the results, garlic was 1.3 times, more effective than turmeric,  at  a  concentration  of  400mg/ml.  In  addition,  each  of  the  concentrations   of  ethanolic  extract  of garlic was more effective than the corresponding concentrations of tumeric extract.

The antimicrobial activity of the garlic extract displayed more  effective  result  against  Candida albicans. The minimum inhibitory concentration test was carried out using concentrations of 200mg/ml  of  each  extract  and  the  MIC  was  observed  at  concentration  of  6.1  and  7.1  of  the  garlic  for  both  ethanol  and   aqueous  extract   and  for  the  tumeric  it was observed  at  concentration  of  4.1  and  5.1  for  both  ethanolic  and  aqueous  extract.  In  addition,  natural  products  such  as  garlic  and  tumeric  promise  a  great  alternation  in  the future as  a  compliment  to  antifungal  drug  in  the  treatment  of  vulvovaginal  candidiasis. The reason is because garlic contains allicin, which  is  one  of  the  active  principles  that  homogenate  a  variety  of  antimicrobial  activities.  Allicin  inhibits  the  growth of fungal and bacterial activities.

CONTENTS

Title page

Page

TABLE OF

Certification

i

Declaration

ii

Acknowledgements

iii

Table of Content

iv

ABSTRACT

v

CHAPTER ONE

Background of study

1

Statement of research problem

2

Justification

3

Aim       and Objectives

4

CHAPTER TWO

Literature review

5

CHAPTER THREE

Experimental procedure

31

Collection of samples

32

Apparatus and Reagents

33

Juice extraction

34

Preparation of inoculums and sub culturing of microbes

35

Screening and accessing for antimicrobial activity

36

Disc diffusion susceptibility test

36

Minimum inhibitory concentration

36

CHAPTER FOUR

Result

37

Biochemical identification of Candida albican

38

Antifungal susceptibility test

39

Minimum inhibitory concentration

40

CHAPTER FIVE

Discussion

41

Antifungal efficacy

42

Conclusion and Recommendation

43

REFERENCES

APPENDIX I

44

APPENDIX II

44

CHAPTER

ONE

INTRODUCTION

  • Background of study

The recurrent nature  of  yeast  infections  and  the  subsequent  use  of  antifungal  medicines  for treatment, pose a  potential  threat  to  women’s  health  and  safety  worldwide,  which  could also give rise to antifungal resistance (Pfaller, 2014).  Statistically  opportunistic  pathogen like Candida species are the main causative agent  of  about  50-70%  causes  morbidity  and  mortality  worldwide  and  thus  a  serious  threat  to   health   public. Candidiasis  is  a  fungal  infection  caused  by  yeast  called  Candida.  Candidiasis   can  also be caused by other species not just Candida  albicans.  Candida  albicans  is  opportunistic  yeast that naturally inhibits the throat, mouth, digestive tract and genitourinary  tract  of  humans. In its yeast state, Candida albicans  lives  in  harmonious  balance  with  other intestinal flora but if the balance  of  the  intestinal  flora  is  disrupted,  it  multiplies  and convert into  its  parasitic  fungal  form,  an  overgrowth  can  lead  to  Candidiasis  (Lisa,  2010).

The pathogen Candida albicans can be found in the oral tract in up  to  80%  of  healthy  humans.

Candida species are  now  recognized  as  causing  disease  with  the  high  frequency  and  are  of the most prevalent sources of nosocomial infection (Veryduyn et al, 1990).

The apparent explosion in  fungal  infection  may  be  explained  by  the  increasing  numbers  of people with impaired  immune  systems  and  those  suffering  from  diabetics,  cystic  fibrosis and leukemia. (Pfaller, 1994).

Garlic has long been used to treat infections around the world; Research supports its antimicrobial activity  against  bacteria,  parasites,  viruses  and  fungi.  Garlic  was  found  to  be a good  alternative  to  an  antifungal  drug  (Fluconazole)  in  the  treatment  of  vaginal  yeast infections. They kill yeast and reduces it symptoms  of  vaginal  redness,  cheesy  discharge and rashes. Garlic enhances the sensitivity of yeast to other antifungal drugs (Hammani and Elmay, 2021).

Traditional  medicine  uses  turmeric  primarily  as  an  anti-inflammatory  agent  and  also  as an antimicrobial against several different  types  of  infections.  Tumeric  impacts  curry  with  its bright yellow color and pungent taste and because this spice is found in most

kitchens, it is one of the common home  remedies  for  yeast  infections.  (Hammani  and  Elmay, 2021)

Candiasis can be manifested as vaginal yeast infection,  oral  candidiasis  (Called  thrush),  and/or the more serious condition. Research  has  clearly  shown  that  garlic  and  turmeric  have antimicrobial activity, inhibiting both the growth and function of Candida albicans (Adetumbi  et  al,  1986).  It  is  interesting  to  note  that  when  garlic  compounds  were studied, it was the ajoene fraction that had the strongest activity against  Candida.  This  suggests that when  shopping  for  garlic  and  turmeric  supplement,  it  is  best  standardized  for its ajoene and not just the typical allicin content.

Garlic and turmeric have an  effect  on  Candida  by  compromising  the  structure  and  integrity of the outer surface of the yeast cell,  oxidizing  certain  essential  proteins.  This  causes inactivation of the yeast enzymes and subsequent microbial growth inhibition.

The treatment regimes used to  manage  candida  infection  vary  and  depend  on  the  anatomical location of the infection foci, the  immune  status  of  the  patients  and  the  associated  risk  factors.  However,  Echinocandis,  extended  spectrum  azoles  and  amphotericin  B  are  generally  the  drugs  of  choice.  Fluconazole  is  considered  the  first-  line drug for patients with candidemia or suspected invasive candidiasis (Jose  A  Hidalgo  2014).

Opportunistic pathogens, like Candida species, are  a  major  cause  of  morbidity  and  mortality worldwide and thus  a  serious  threat  to  public  health  (Pfaller  et.al,  2014; Mathaiou et al., 2015; paper et al., 2016). Further, Candida species  can  cause  oral  Candidiasis, Cutaneous Candidiasis etc. (Wachtler et al.2012). Candidemia is  the  most  frequent hospital  infection  accounting  for  up  to  15%  of  bloodstream  infection  and  candida species is the main causative agent in 50-70%  of  systemic  fungal  infections.  (Cornely et al.,2012); Lionakis and Netea,2013; Barchiesi et al.,2016)

The pathogenesis of Candida species is poorly understood and the rate of  infection  is  increasing rapidly. Furthermore, a steady increment in resistance to traditional antifungal

has resulted in the need to control; Candidal infections  through  early  diagnosis  and  alternative prevention of Candidiasis.

Within the limited antifungal armamentarium, the  azole  antifungal  are  the  most  frequent  class used to treat Candida infection.Azole antifungal  such  as  fluconazole  are  often  preferred treatment I many Candida infections are they are inexpensive,  exhibit  limited  toxicity and  are  available  for  oral  administration  Azole.  However,  the  presence  of  intrinsic and developed resistance against  azole  antifungals  has  been  extensively  documented  among  several  Candida  species  (David  Vallenet,2017).  The  advent  of  original and reemergence of classical fungal  diseases  have  occurred  as  a  consequence  of  the development of the  antifungal  resistance.  It  is  thus  imperative  that  new  and  satisfactory therapy for fungal diseases be developed  alternative  to  present  day  drugs.  Natural products from and  traditional  medicines  provide  new  promises  in  the  modern  clinic (Ankri S, Mirelman D 1999).

These natural products developed  alternative  drugs  that  are  more  efficient  and  tolerant  than the antifungal drugs. The reasons are as follows:

Garlic may work synergistically with antifungal drugs. Allicin enhances the activity and decreases drug resistance of several antifungal drugs including amphotericin  B  and  fluconazole (Hammani and Elmay 2021). Furthermore,  garlic  enhances  the  sensitivity  of yeast to other antifungals drugs.

Tumeric contains curcumin which possesses  antifungal  activity.  This  bright  yellow  compound kills Candida by increasing oxidative stress leading to  early  cell  death  of  the  yeast to hyphae form, a major virulence factor of Candida, in addition,  curcumin  has  synergetic  effect  when  taken  with  antifungal  drugs  (Fulconazole)  to  improve  their  efficacy and reduce drug resistance (Hammani and Elmay 2020).

                             STATEMENT PROBLEM

Garlic  contain  allicin  which  possess  a  compound  called  ajoene,  Garlic  has  long  been  used to treat infections around the world. Research supports its antimicrobial activities

against bacteria,  viruses,  parasites  and  fungi.  Garlic  was  found  to  be  a  good  alternative  to antifungal drug in the treatment of Vulvovaginal infection (David Vallenet, 2017).

Tumeric on the other hand  contains  curcumin  which  possesses  antifungal  activity.  The  bright yellow compound kills Candida albicans by increasing  oxidative  stress  leading  to  early  cell  death  of  the  yeast.it  also  prevents  the  transition  from  yeast  to  hyphae  form,    a major virulence factor of the Candida albicans (Hammani and Elmay,2021).

Many women suffer from chronic recurrent yeast  infection  often  antifungal  drugs  that  provide temporary relief but the  infection  soon  returns.  Antifungal  drugs  are  often  effective, but  might  lead  to  serious  adverse  effects  that  some  individuals  prefer  not  to  use  them,  furthermore  drug  resistance  is  on  the  increase  and  as  a  result,  antifungal  drugs are not always effective. Individuals thus often seek natural or home remedies for treatment of yeast infections, either as a stand-alone treatment  complement  to  antifungal  drugs (Harrison and Brawled, 2018).

Unavailability or lack of access to health care facilities due to low  income  or  poverty, especially  in  the  rural  area,  (David  Vallenet,2017)  has  led  to  self-  medication  through  the use of natural  plants/herbs  such  as  garlic  and  tumeric.  The  research  base  on  testing  the effectiveness and  creating  alternative  using  garlic  and  tumeric  to  generate  a  solution  to the problem and also serve as first aid treatment specifically to less privileged.

                JUSTIFICATION

The threat of antifungal resistance and the many side effects of taking synthetic chemotherapeutic agents necessitate the urgent need for the discovery of natural herbal alternatives. This is especially  critical  for  people  with  low  income  in  rural  and  urban  areas and without access to standard health care facilities

Traditionally, garlic and turmeric has been used to treat urinary tract infection caused by Candida albicans.  Garlic  (Allium  sativum)  has  been  traditionally  used  for  the  treatment  of diseases  since  ancient  times.  A  wide  range  of  microorganisms  including  bacteria,  fungi,  protozoa  and  viruses  are  known  to  be  sensitive  to  garlic  and  turmeric  preparations. Allicin and other sulphur compounds are thought to be major antimicrobial

factors in garlic and turmeric, because they contain oil and water-soluble organosulfur compounds (Pertanika, 2015).

The efficacy of garlic  and  turmeric  against  VVC  has  been  investigated  elsewhere  but  to  the best of our knowledge, there has been no exact published data available on  isolates  obtained from Barau Dikko hospital, Kaduna.

                     AIM

  • To analyze the inhibitory potential  of  garlic  and  turmeric  in  the  treatment  of  Candida albicans associated with Vulvovaginal candidiasis.

OBJECTIVES

  • Analyze the inhibitory  potentials  of  both  aqueous  and  ethanolic  extract  of  garlic  and turmeric on Candida albicans
    • To establish  the  Minimum  Inhibitory  Concentration  (MIC)  of  extracts  of  Garlic  and Turmeric.
    • To characterize the isolates of Candida albicans.